"One day, I happened to take a gentleman home and he had the smallest penis I had ever seen,"Arciuolo tells Rolling Stone. "And basically that man worked so hard for my pleasure that I remember telling my friends about it the next day, saying, 'We should throw a pageant for these guys, they work much harder than guys that are well hung.'"
Among this year's competitors is Rip Van Dinkle, who read about a prior pageant and entered after realizing he both had a small penis and had never been to Brooklyn. The Puzzle Master is a returning contestant, who came up short last year, but hopes his phallic-friendly rendition of the "Goldfinger" theme — aptly renamed "Gold-dinger" — will earn him the crown.
The contest itself was divided into three categories — formal wear, swimwear and a talent show — and it's all hilariously bawdy, over-the-top and even inspiring. "America needs more orgies," bellowed one contest named Cromwell. "In that room I saw white people, I saw black people, I saw Asians, Hispanics, I saw everybody sucking each other off and it was the most beautiful picture of racial harmony I have ever seen!"
While Cromwell's heartwarming portrait of the American melting pot didn't win him the title, check out the video to see which contestants got shafted and who walked away with the crown.